A Blockbuster shareholder has filed a complaint with the court handling Blockbuster Inc.’s bankruptcy alleging CEO Jim Keyes and investor Carl Icahn conspired prior to the filing to manipulate the outcome and enrich key stakeholders.
Dallas-based Blockbuster filed a pre-packaged Chapter 11 filing Sept. 23, citing debts exceeding $1.4 billion.
Shareholder Jasbir Sandhu Oct. 12 filed the complaint with U.S. Bankruptcy Court in the Southern District of New York, claiming Keyes and Icahn worked together to thwart recapitalization efforts and increase Icahn’s return on investment by dragging the price of the bond (debt) lower.
Icahn, who once held a board seat and over time quietly divested his ownership stake in Blockbuster prior to the filing, successfully converted his remaining shares into bonds. He is considered to have played a key role in pushing through major tenants of the filing.
Sandhu, who claims to have more than 200 signed petitions in support of the complaint, alleges Keyes purposely kept Blockbuster Express kiosks operations, Blockbuster Canada and other foreign assets from the bankruptcy in order to lower the company’s portfolio value. The investor said shareholder equity should have included all Blockbuster properties.
“Selling a few international assets would have avoided Chapter 11, but Keyes followed the path that was more favorable to Carl Icahn,” Sandhu wrote in the complaint.
He is calling for a formal inquiry by the Securities and Exchange Commission.
The complaint, though separate, is based on similar concerns raised by a group called Blockbustershareholders.com, which claims 26% of the company’s common shareholders and has vowed legal action against the Blockbuster, according to Sandhu.
“Our objective is to get full disclosure from Blockbuster about the recapitalization efforts and Carl Icahn's influence,” Sandhu wrote in an e-mail.
He supports his claims in part by referencing an interview Keyes did with TheWrap.com, in which Keyes called Icahn a “good friend,” and said the maverick investor could be “even more helpful on the outside [of Blockbuster].”
Sandhu believes the repercussions individuals face filing bankruptcy (flagged credit rating) should also apply to corporations that file for Chapter 11. He said it is too easy for debt-laden companies to file for bankruptcy and wipe the slate clean, with little impact on key executives.
“I do not see Keyes moving out of Blockbuster,” Sandhu said, alluding to media reports the CEO would leave the company when it emerges from bankruptcy. “Worst-case scenario: I see a damage control initiative by Blockbuster [that] would … move Keyes to another Icahn influenced company.”
Analyst Michael Pachter with Wedbush Securities in Los Angeles, who has covered Blockbuster for years, said Sandhu’s allegations are without merit.
“It’s sour grapes,” Pachter said. “Neither of them is a bad guy. It’s a lame allegation.”
Dallas-based Blockbuster filed a pre-packaged Chapter 11 filing Sept. 23, citing debts exceeding $1.4 billion.
Shareholder Jasbir Sandhu Oct. 12 filed the complaint with U.S. Bankruptcy Court in the Southern District of New York, claiming Keyes and Icahn worked together to thwart recapitalization efforts and increase Icahn’s return on investment by dragging the price of the bond (debt) lower.
Icahn, who once held a board seat and over time quietly divested his ownership stake in Blockbuster prior to the filing, successfully converted his remaining shares into bonds. He is considered to have played a key role in pushing through major tenants of the filing.
Sandhu, who claims to have more than 200 signed petitions in support of the complaint, alleges Keyes purposely kept Blockbuster Express kiosks operations, Blockbuster Canada and other foreign assets from the bankruptcy in order to lower the company’s portfolio value. The investor said shareholder equity should have included all Blockbuster properties.
“Selling a few international assets would have avoided Chapter 11, but Keyes followed the path that was more favorable to Carl Icahn,” Sandhu wrote in the complaint.
He is calling for a formal inquiry by the Securities and Exchange Commission.
The complaint, though separate, is based on similar concerns raised by a group called Blockbustershareholders.com, which claims 26% of the company’s common shareholders and has vowed legal action against the Blockbuster, according to Sandhu.
“Our objective is to get full disclosure from Blockbuster about the recapitalization efforts and Carl Icahn's influence,” Sandhu wrote in an e-mail.
He supports his claims in part by referencing an interview Keyes did with TheWrap.com, in which Keyes called Icahn a “good friend,” and said the maverick investor could be “even more helpful on the outside [of Blockbuster].”
Sandhu believes the repercussions individuals face filing bankruptcy (flagged credit rating) should also apply to corporations that file for Chapter 11. He said it is too easy for debt-laden companies to file for bankruptcy and wipe the slate clean, with little impact on key executives.
“I do not see Keyes moving out of Blockbuster,” Sandhu said, alluding to media reports the CEO would leave the company when it emerges from bankruptcy. “Worst-case scenario: I see a damage control initiative by Blockbuster [that] would … move Keyes to another Icahn influenced company.”
Analyst Michael Pachter with Wedbush Securities in Los Angeles, who has covered Blockbuster for years, said Sandhu’s allegations are without merit.
“It’s sour grapes,” Pachter said. “Neither of them is a bad guy. It’s a lame allegation.”